You Can See Everything: A New Documentary on Elizabeth Holmes
The highly anticipated documentary, You Can See Everything, directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, offers a unique and captivating exploration of the enigmatic figure of Elizabeth Holmes. The film, which premiered at the New York Film Festival, has garnered significant buzz and critical acclaim, with speculation even suggesting it could be nominated for an Oscar for Best Picture, a first for a documentary.
The Documentary's Genesis
You Can See Everything follows Holmes, her partner Billy Evans, and their two children in the weeks leading up to her reporting to federal prison in May 2023. Holmes' decision to grant the filmmakers access seems to be part of her effort to assert her innocence and reshape her public image. This is evident in her interview with the New York Times, where she presents herself as a devoted mother and volunteer at a rape crisis center, a portrayal that was widely criticized for its leniency.
The choice of Fielder and Oppenheim as directors is intriguing. Fielder is known for his acerbic, quasi-real television series, while Oppenheim is a sharp documentarian and director of the feature film Primetime. Despite their unique styles, Holmes and Evans granted them unprecedented access, allowing them to capture intimate moments up until the day she entered prison.
Holmes on Camera
In the documentary, Holmes appears genuine and unblinking, insisting she never lied, her medical device worked, and she has been unfairly vilified. Her account is juxtaposed with Fielder's baffled skepticism, expressed through silent reactions that are both funny and thought-provoking. The audience is put in the position of questioning her sincerity, just as Fielder does.
A Meta Twist
The most remarkable part of the documentary comes halfway through, when Fielder introduces another person into the narrative. This person, in conversation with Fielder, offers a new perspective, questioning Holmes' sincerity and suggesting she might be either extremely manipulative or delusional. The film leaves these possibilities open, allowing the audience to draw their own conclusions.
Holmes' Ongoing Fame and Defiant Image
Holmes remains as famous and defiant as ever. Her active X account showcases her determination to prove her innocence and return to her family. News organizations have reported on her transfer to a halfway house next year as if tracking a Hollywood celebrity. The public's fascination with Holmes persists, driven by the unanswered questions surrounding her case and her jaw-dropping assertions of innocence.
The Impact of You Can See Everything
The enthusiastic response to You Can See Everything is attributed to its bold exploration of the documentary genre, blending entertainment with a serious subtext about truth and image-making. The film's release in US cinemas on October 16 and UK cinemas on November 20 is highly anticipated, promising to continue the public's engagement with the complex and captivating figure of Elizabeth Holmes.